Jury · Process
Judging Process
How nominations are evaluated: independent judges, a published scoring framework, and clear minimum standards for winners.
Principles
- Independence: judges evaluate nominations independently using the published scoring framework for each category.
- Integrity: judges must disclose conflicts of interest and recuse where required.
- Confidentiality: nominations and scoring are confidential until official publication.
Evaluation Stages
- Administrative screening for completeness, eligibility basics, and integrity checks.
- Judge assignment based on subject-matter expertise and conflict-of-interest screening.
- Scoring by multiple judges using the category's criteria and weights.
- Quality assurance (consistency checks) and aggregation of results.
Scoring Methodology
- Scoring scale: each criterion is scored from 1 to 10.
- Weights: each criterion has a percentage weight; weights sum to 100%.
- Final Score: for each nomination, we calculate the average of judges' weighted scores and convert it to a 0–100 scale.
Winner Determination
Each category produces one winner or no winner — not all categories produce a winner each cycle. This ensures that only genuinely excellent nominations receive the Category Winner designation.
Minimum Standards for Winners
- Final Score threshold: at least 80.0 out of 100.0.
- Primary Criterion threshold: at least 8.0 out of 10.0 on the criterion with the highest weight in that category.
If the top-scoring nomination does not meet both thresholds, the category remains without a winner for the cycle.
Feedback
Where available, judges may provide concise feedback intended to be constructive and professional. Feedback is not guaranteed for every nomination and may be edited for confidentiality and compliance.
Appeals and Disputes
Scoring decisions are final. The Organizer may correct administrative errors or resolve eligibility issues in accordance with the Terms & Conditions.